I had never been so frightened of the dark until the night my six-year-old daughter disappeared.
The police were searching the neighborhood.
Rain was soaking the backyard.
And a black crow was sitting on our fence, looking straight at me.
I knew that bird.
His name was Edgar.
There was one white feather on his left wing, and for thirty-four mornings, he had come to our porch looking for peanuts.
But that evening, he wasn't looking for food.
He had brought me something.
A small pink butterfly hair clip.
My daughter Birdie had been wearing it when I last saw her.
I tried to tell the deputy standing beside me.
He was a large man with a rain jacket pulled over his uniform. His name was Harris.
"That's my daughter's clip," I told him.
He looked down at the little pink butterfly lying near the porch.
"Are you certain?"
"Yes."
I could barely make the word come out.
"She wears it all the time."
Harris lowered his flashlight.
Behind us, another officer was speaking into a radio. Farther down the street, people were moving between parked police vehicles.
Everyone was looking for Birdie.
Nobody knew where she was.
And the one thing I had been able to recognize in hours was sitting on the wet concrete at my feet.
I bent to pick it up.
My fingers were shaking so badly that I almost dropped it.
One of its wings was damaged.
I remembered fastening that same clip into Birdie's brown hair.
I remembered her turning her head toward the mirror to see whether it sat straight.
Now I was holding it outside in the rain.
Without her.
Edgar called from the fence.
I looked up.
He was watching me.
Then he lifted his wings, flew several yards along the fence, and settled on another wooden post.
He turned around.
He called again.
I stood.
"Harris, look at him."
The deputy followed my eyes.
"What about him?"
"He wants us to go that way."
Harris studied the crow.
"Mrs. Becker, I understand you're upset."
"No. Please listen."
I stepped toward the yard.
Edgar moved again.
He flew a little farther and stopped.
The bird kept turning back toward the house.
He was not behaving the way he did during our ordinary mornings.
Those mornings had been simple.
I would bring out a few unsalted peanuts, put them on the porch railing, and move away.
Edgar would wait until I gave him space.
Then he would come down.
Sometimes he left small objects behind.
A bottle cap.
A brass button.
A silver earring.
A piece of green sea glass.
Birdie kept those little things in a jar on her bedroom windowsill.
She believed Edgar was giving her presents.
I never corrected her.
What would have been the point?
She was six years old.
She had found something harmless to love.
And after the changes our family had already been through, I wasn't going to take that small pleasure away from her.
But not everyone liked Edgar.
Our homeowners association president, Mr. Dennison, had made that clear.
He complained about the peanuts.
He complained about the crow landing on my porch.
He said I was encouraging wildlife to become a neighborhood problem.
One day, he even mentioned keeping a pellet gun in his garage.
He said it would be an easy way to get rid of a troublesome bird.
I remembered how casually he had said it.
As though Edgar were a broken garden hose.
As though anything inconvenient could simply be removed.
I had argued with him.
He had threatened a five-hundred-dollar fine.
And somewhere in all that foolish fighting over a crow, I had failed to imagine that something much worse could happen.
That afternoon, Birdie had gone missing.
She had disappeared around two-thirty.
By the time the rain grew heavy, the police were involved, neighbors were searching, and I was standing outside with a broken hair clip.
I had already asked myself the same questions so many times that the words had stopped meaning anything.
Had I looked everywhere?
Had I called loudly enough?
Had I missed something obvious?
I couldn't answer any of them.
Edgar cried out again.
I started toward him.
Harris caught my arm.
"Please stay near the house."
I turned to him.
"He's showing us something."
"Who is?"
"The crow."
He looked uncomfortable.
"Mrs. Becker, we can't assume an animal knows where your daughter is."
"I know how that sounds."
I pointed toward the fence.
"But look at what he brought me."
Harris glanced at the butterfly clip.
Then at Edgar.
For a moment, neither of us spoke.
Rain drummed against the porch roof.
Water ran from the gutter into a puddle beside my shoes.
I could hear someone calling Birdie's name two houses away.
Then Edgar moved to the next post.
He stopped.
He waited.
I pulled my arm free.
"I'm not asking you to believe a story about a clever bird. I'm asking you to look where he's going."
Harris pressed his lips together.
I could tell he was deciding whether I was giving him useful information or simply falling apart in front of him.
Maybe it was both.
I didn't care.
"My daughter is out there."
My voice broke.
"And right now, this bird is the only thing that's brought me anything of hers."
Harris lifted his radio.
He informed dispatch that the mother of the missing child had identified a possible route along the western fence toward the canal.
Then he waved two other deputies over.
One carried a flashlight.
The other had a map of the neighborhood.
Harris pointed toward the backyard.
"We're checking that direction."
The younger deputy looked surprised.
"Did someone see the child?"
"Not yet."
Harris looked at me.
"But we're checking."
I wanted to thank him.
I couldn't.
Edgar was already moving.
We stepped off the porch and crossed the grass.
The ground had become soft from hours of rain.
Mud stuck to the bottoms of my shoes.
I had forgotten to bring a proper coat.
My sleeves were wet.
My hair clung to my face.
None of it mattered.
Ahead of us, Edgar landed on another fence post.
He shook himself.
Then he looked back.
"That's him," I whispered.
Harris raised his flashlight.
"Stay close, Mrs. Becker. Don't go ahead of us."
I nodded.
For the first time since Birdie disappeared, we were moving toward something instead of wandering between places we had already checked.
Our backyard bordered a stretch of shared green space.
Beyond it, there was a walking trail, a row of cottonwood trees, and an irrigation canal.
I had warned Birdie about that canal.
Even when the water looked shallow, I told her to keep her distance.
The banks were steep in places.
The mud could be slippery.
After heavy rain, the current was stronger than it appeared.
She knew those rules.
At least, I believed she did.
I had explained them so often that I sometimes wondered whether she was tired of hearing my voice.
Now I would have given anything to hear her complain about another warning.
We reached the edge of the yard.
Edgar flew toward the trees.
The younger deputy angled his flashlight through the branches.
"There."
A black shape moved between two trunks.
Then the crow settled on a low branch.
His white feather caught the light.
I pointed.
"Please don't lose him."
"We see him," Harris said.
We crossed the wet green space.
I could hear the canal now.
Usually, from our backyard, it made only a faint trickling sound.
That night was different.
Water was rushing through the channel.
The noise grew louder with every step.
I felt sick.
Birdie had always been small for her age.
I knew exactly how much effort it took her to climb onto the kitchen stool.
I knew how carefully she stepped over puddles when she didn't want her socks wet.
I knew she still reached for my hand when crossing a busy street.
And I was walking toward fast water without knowing whether she was anywhere near it.
Edgar descended toward a willow tree.
Harris suddenly held out his arm.
"Stop here."
We froze.
His flashlight moved across the mud.
At first, I saw nothing but wet leaves and flattened grass.
Then I saw the marks.
Little shoe prints.
Several of them.
They were close together, pressed into the soft bank.
I covered my mouth.
"Birdie?"
Harris knelt.
"Don't come closer."
I stopped with one foot raised.
He examined the marks while the second deputy shone a light beside him.
There were two different sizes.
One set belonged to someone with small feet.
The other was larger.
Much larger.
The little prints went toward the canal.
The bigger ones appeared to approach from another direction.
Harris touched the ground beside one impression without disturbing it.
"Get photographs of these."
The younger deputy reached for his equipment.
I stared at the larger marks.
"Who made those?"
"We don't know."
"Was someone with her?"
"We need to examine them first."
He was being careful.
I understood that later.
At the time, every answer that wasn't certainty felt unbearable.
I wanted someone to tell me Birdie was alive.
I wanted someone to explain why her clip had been on my porch and why her footprints were near dangerous water.
Instead, Harris studied the ground.
Then a deputy called from beneath the willow tree.
"There's something here."
I turned before he finished speaking.
He was pointing toward a low branch hanging over the muddy slope.
Something pink was tangled in it.
At first, I thought it was a piece of clothing.
Then the flashlight settled on it.
A backpack.
Small.
Pink.
With an embroidered rabbit on the front.
I knew that rabbit.
I had watched Birdie run her finger over its ears when she was nervous.
"That's her bag."
My voice came out thin.
Then I shouted it.
"That's Birdie's backpack!"
I tried to move forward.
Harris blocked me gently.
"Let us get it."
The deputy approached the branch.
He carefully freed the strap.
One side of the backpack was torn.
Mud covered the bottom.
Water dripped from the zipper.
The deputy held it up for Harris to inspect.
I wanted to snatch it from him.
I wanted to open every pocket.
I wanted to find a note saying my little girl was somewhere safe.
Harris unzipped the bag.
Inside was her lunch container.
Her little coloring book.
And her stuffed rabbit.
That rabbit slept beside her pillow every night.
She called it her favorite even though she had three others almost exactly like it.
Seeing it inside the muddy backpack hurt more than I could explain.
It belonged in her bed.
Not beside a canal.
Harris looked through the remaining contents.
Then he stopped.
He pulled out a folded sheet of paper.
I recognized the size.
Birdie liked to tear pages from her coloring book and make maps.
She drew maps of our house.
Maps of the garden.
Maps showing where she imagined squirrels slept.
Harris carefully opened the paper beneath his flashlight.
There was a child's drawing.
A house.
Some open grass.
A large black bird.
And one white mark on its wing.
Edgar.
I stepped closer.
"What did she draw?"
Harris turned the paper so I could see.
Beneath the picture, Birdie had written a short message in uneven capital letters.
EDGAR SHOWED ME HERE.
I read it once.
Then again.
My hand went to my mouth.
I didn't understand.
Birdie had drawn our home and the place behind it.
She had drawn the crow she loved.
And she had written that he had shown her somewhere.
But why had the paper ended up in her backpack?
And why was the backpack hanging over the water?
Harris studied the picture.
"Is this her handwriting?"
"Yes."
"You're sure?"
I nodded.
"She makes her G that way."
I pointed at the page.
"She always does."
He folded it carefully.
I could see he was thinking.
So was I.
But my thoughts kept returning to the same awful possibility.
Birdie had reached this place.
Something had happened.
And someone else might have been nearby.
Edgar flew down from the willow.
He landed on a branch extending over the canal.
The movement startled all three deputies.
Then he began calling.
His voice was sharp.
Repeated.
Almost harsh enough to hurt my ears.
He wasn't moving away anymore.
He stayed there.
Directly above the water.
Harris turned toward the canal.
He raised his flashlight and studied the bank below the branch.
Then he spoke into his radio.
He requested search-and-rescue personnel at the canal immediately.
I grabbed his sleeve.
"What did you see?"
"Nothing definite."
"Then why are you calling them?"
He looked at the swollen water.
"Because we have evidence your daughter came this way, and we need people equipped to search safely."
I looked at Edgar.
He was still calling.
The white feather on his wing moved each time he shifted.
I remembered Birdie standing at the window with her jar of little gifts.
I remembered her asking whether Edgar knew she was his friend.
I had told her I thought he recognized us.
Now, beside that dark canal, I was asking myself whether he had recognized something else.
Something about Birdie.
Something that might help us find her.
I lowered my eyes to the muddy bank.
There were footprints.
A torn backpack.
A drawing.
And the sound of rushing water.
For the first time that night, the search had reached a place where my daughter had definitely been.
That should have been a relief.
Instead, I was terrified.
Because I still didn't know where she had gone afterward.
Click here to continue reading: PART 2: We Found My Daughter’s Red Boot Caught in the Canal Reeds, and the Marks in the Mud Told Us Something Had Gone Terribly Wrong
I Begged Three Police Officers to Follow a Crow Through the Rain Because He Was Carrying Something That Belonged to My Missing Daughter
Part 1 of 10
